Files
TheLadder/tools/story-to-pack/probe/wharton/claude/summaries.json
T
JesseMarkowitzandClaude Opus 5 e5617b86ba Replace clustering with a catalogue, and hand-write the references to judge it against
The pipeline's embed-and-cluster step is dead, and this commit holds both the
evidence for that and the step proposed to replace it.

Predicaments. Scenes are re-described as "what the person is up against", with
no names, jobs or places, then embedded and clustered (redescribe.py,
topic_words.py, topic_share.py). The pilot chose qwen3:14b over 3b by reading
both side by side. Two defects the pilot exposed are fixed: split.py missed
titles in quotes and a contents subtitle after a dash, so three stories had been
merged into their neighbours, and strip_names.py read New York place names as
people. The corrected corpus is probe/v2 (97 stories, 839 scenes);
carry_summaries.py reuses the 829 unchanged v1 summaries. Topic share fell from
20% to 13% at k=60, short of the pre-registered 10%.

Hand references. Three corpora were read scene by scene and written up by hand,
under the same prompt rules the local models get, as a baseline to judge them
against: O. Henry (probe/v2/claude, 839 scenes, 20 situations), Wharton's
Descent of Man (probe/wharton, 262 scenes, 16 groups) and Jacobs's The Lady of
the Barge (probe/jacobs, 157 scenes, 19 groups). Each has its own README and a
readable page. No inference was used for any of them.

Catalogue. probe/catalogue maps every hand group in the three references onto 36
situation entries, with an answer key per corpus and one recurrence rule applied
to all three. classify.py assigns a scene one entry or none, leave-one-corpus-
out; score.py checks it against the key, with a self-test on random labels.

Why clustering is out: hand-written predicaments, embedded and clustered exactly
as the model's were, agree with the hand grouping at ARI 0.05 — no better than
the 14B text's 0.07. Better rewriting cannot rescue it. Embeddings cannot even
shortlist: the hand label is the nearest entry 13% of the time and in the top 8
half the time.

The classification runs are not here. The dev and test runs are pre-registered
in probe/catalogue/README.md with the bar set beforehand, and are blocked on the
inference host, whose GPU has fallen off the PCIe bus three times. The 30-scene
partial output in out/ is not a result.

Review page. The situation review is now a browser page rather than JSON edited
by hand (review_page.py, review_page_logic.cjs with Node tests, format schema
v2). It has never been rendered in a real browser.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_014BygvsUXV9eU6oHkTCkKZ1
2026-09-20 17:19:42 -04:00

1054 lines
41 KiB
JSON

{
"source": "hand-written by Claude, reading each scene",
"field": "summary",
"summaries": [
{
"chunk": 0,
"summary": "A scholar returns from a rare holiday alone, secretly delighted by a private idea he has hidden from his wife and colleagues."
},
{
"chunk": 1,
"summary": "Alone in the woods for the first time since his marriage, a scholar indulges an idea he has never had the freedom to pursue."
},
{
"chunk": 2,
"summary": "A comfortable, dutiful marriage leaves a scholar no companion in the thinking that is his real life."
},
{
"chunk": 3,
"summary": "A scholar's modest earnings must support his family, and his wife economises to keep up appearances while taking pride in his obscure reputation."
},
{
"chunk": 4,
"summary": "Overworked supporting his family, a scholar breaks down, and in the enforced rest surveys how his field is seen by the public."
},
{
"chunk": 5,
"summary": "A scholar observes that his once-private discipline has become a popular fashion that everyone reads and holds opinions on."
},
{
"chunk": 6,
"summary": "Angered and amused by popular pseudo-science, a scholar resolves to write a parody of it so absurd the public will laugh at its own prophets."
},
{
"chunk": 7,
"summary": "A scholar brings his manuscript to an old college friend now a prosperous popular publisher, keeping its satirical purpose a secret."
},
{
"chunk": 8,
"summary": "The publisher warns the book may be too learned to sell, but agrees to take it; the author waves off the question of payment."
},
{
"chunk": 9,
"summary": "The publisher has rushed the book into print and congratulates the author on abandoning the scepticism of his youth."
},
{
"chunk": 10,
"summary": "The publisher takes the parody for a sincere confession of faith; the author, realising, bursts out laughing."
},
{
"chunk": 11,
"summary": "The author explains the book is a satire; the publisher, offended, suggests it need not be read ironically at all."
},
{
"chunk": 12,
"summary": "The publisher offers to sell the book as sincere, promising a mass success, and asks the author to let it stand as his real conviction."
},
{
"chunk": 13,
"summary": "The author agrees to stay silent, telling himself the joke has only grown larger and that nothing in the book will change."
},
{
"chunk": 14,
"summary": "Short of money after illness, the author accepts a large advance, sure his colleagues will see through the book and his reputation will be safe."
},
{
"chunk": 15,
"summary": "The book is already printing, so resistance seems futile; his wife, having seen a glowing review, asks why he kept it from her."
},
{
"chunk": 16,
"summary": "The publisher's advertising campaign floods the country, making the book impossible to escape."
},
{
"chunk": 17,
"summary": "The author hides in his work on publication day, then reads a serious review praising his mock platitudes as noble truths."
},
{
"chunk": 18,
"summary": "Every paper follows the first review, and the publisher predicts the book will sell for years; the author is alarmed by its staying power."
},
{
"chunk": 19,
"summary": "The publisher praises the book's sentiment and pays more; the author, pestered by journalists, is asked by his wife whether interviews pay."
},
{
"chunk": 20,
"summary": "His wife confesses their son has run into debt since the book's fame; the author offers to write a lucrative popular series to cover it."
},
{
"chunk": 21,
"summary": "Having sworn not to extend the fraud, the author begins the popular series within the hour, mainly to be rid of his wife's demands."
},
{
"chunk": 22,
"summary": "Fame opens society to the author; charmed by clever women, he grows used to telling how the book first came to him."
},
{
"chunk": 23,
"summary": "The author gives paid interviews on every subject and lends his face to advertisements, which keeps his household solvent."
},
{
"chunk": 24,
"summary": "The author leads a double life, courted by the public while his real research goes on unnoticed by colleagues who ignore the book."
},
{
"chunk": 25,
"summary": "The author's earnings buy him instruments for real research; nearing a genuine discovery, he confides it to one trusted colleague."
},
{
"chunk": 26,
"summary": "A colleague urges him to drop everything and write his serious book; the author asks his publisher for an advance and is refused."
},
{
"chunk": 27,
"summary": "The publisher says the old book is fading and offers a big advance only for a sequel; the author declares he will write a serious book instead."
},
{
"chunk": 28,
"summary": "Warned that popularity perishes, the author wavers, takes the advance on the sequel, and tells himself the serious book can wait six months."
},
{
"chunk": 29,
"summary": "A newly married man waits eagerly for his wife on their first evening in his own house."
},
{
"chunk": 30,
"summary": "The honeymoon is cut short by the illness of the wife's daughter from her first marriage; the husband takes comfort in his wife's calm."
},
{
"chunk": 31,
"summary": "The husband recalls the gossip about his wife's obscure origins and first divorce, which society chose to blame on the unknown first husband."
},
{
"chunk": 32,
"summary": "The wife's second marriage bought her social standing, ended in a divorce that made her sympathetic, and friends doubted the wisdom of her third."
},
{
"chunk": 33,
"summary": "The wife arrives worried: her first husband's lawyer has written about his right to see the child."
},
{
"chunk": 34,
"summary": "The first husband has the legal right to visit his sick daughter in the new husband's house; the husband reluctantly agrees."
},
{
"chunk": 35,
"summary": "Fleeing the house on the visiting day, the husband is squeezed next to his wife's second ex-husband on a crowded train and must make small talk."
},
{
"chunk": 36,
"summary": "The ex-husband mentions business with the husband's ailing partner; the husband escapes the train and welcomes the extra work."
},
{
"chunk": 37,
"summary": "At lunch the husband sees the ex-husband savouring his coffee with brandy and envies his ease."
},
{
"chunk": 38,
"summary": "The husband comes home and finds his wife serene and happy, having apparently put the day's visitor out of mind."
},
{
"chunk": 39,
"summary": "His wife says she let the nurse receive the visitor, then absent-mindedly pours brandy into her husband's coffee as her ex-husband took it, and blushes."
},
{
"chunk": 40,
"summary": "The husband's ill partner asks him to handle an important deal for his wife's ex-husband; for the firm's sake he agrees."
},
{
"chunk": 41,
"summary": "The ex-husband behaves well in the meeting and lets slip that he was once desperate for money; the husband is glad to seem the steadier man."
},
{
"chunk": 42,
"summary": "Coming home unexpectedly, the husband finds his wife's first husband, a mild shabby man, waiting in his library."
},
{
"chunk": 43,
"summary": "The husband is polite to the first husband, then retreats upset that this man has the run of his house."
},
{
"chunk": 44,
"summary": "Seeing the first husband's cheap manners, the husband pictures his wife's humble former life and is disturbed by how completely she has left it behind."
},
{
"chunk": 45,
"summary": "The husband suspects his wife misrepresented her first marriage; later the first husband asks to speak to him about the child's governess."
},
{
"chunk": 46,
"summary": "The first husband reveals he did see the wife on the first visit, exposing her lie, and says the governess is making the girl dishonest."
},
{
"chunk": 47,
"summary": "The first husband asserts his legal right to a voice in the girl's upbringing; the husband, learning of the man's sacrifices for his daughter, grows uneasy about his wife's account."
},
{
"chunk": 48,
"summary": "The wife calls the first husband ungentlemanly and cries; the husband sees she knew his rights all along and expects to be pitied."
},
{
"chunk": 49,
"summary": "The first husband uses his rights modestly; meanwhile the husband must keep meeting the second ex-husband on business he cannot pass on."
},
{
"chunk": 50,
"summary": "The husband finds his wife chatting with her second ex-husband at a ball; she offers to do whatever he wishes about speaking to him."
},
{
"chunk": 51,
"summary": "Sickened by his wife's endless pliancy, the husband agrees she should be civil; society praises her for smoothing an awkward situation."
},
{
"chunk": 52,
"summary": "The husband feels he owns only a share in his wife, with her former husbands as partners, and resents her tactful acquiescence."
},
{
"chunk": 53,
"summary": "Habit dulls the husband's objections; he reckons that his predecessors trained his wife to make him comfortable."
},
{
"chunk": 54,
"summary": "The husband comes to accept the first husband's visits, and one evening offers him a cigar and a seat by the fire."
},
{
"chunk": 55,
"summary": "The second ex-husband arrives unannounced on business while the first husband sits there; all three men stand awkwardly as tea is laid out."
},
{
"chunk": 56,
"summary": "The wife enters, greets both former husbands graciously, and the three men stand awkward before her."
},
{
"chunk": 57,
"summary": "The wife smooths the moment by pouring tea for all three men, and the husband takes his cup with a laugh."
},
{
"chunk": 58,
"summary": "A society wife who has just published a daring novel dreads the arrival of press clippings now that her uncle, a bishop, is in town."
},
{
"chunk": 59,
"summary": "She complains that her husband is embarrassingly proud of the book and will read the reviews aloud to visitors; she fears a scandal."
},
{
"chunk": 60,
"summary": "She insists her provocative title is honest, not commercial, and fears she has dragged her husband's name through the mire."
},
{
"chunk": 61,
"summary": "She says using a pen-name would be cowardice; her cousin, a hard-up hack writer, says an attack from the press would make her rich."
},
{
"chunk": 62,
"summary": "She claims to speak for unhappy women; her divorced cousin warns that women with a past avoid stirring up mud. The bishop's arrival terrifies her."
},
{
"chunk": 63,
"summary": "The bishop arrives; he favours this niece over her cousin, whose cheap books outsell his own and who refused his advice during her divorce."
},
{
"chunk": 64,
"summary": "Left alone with the bishop, the novelist feigns interest in his book to deflect talk of her own, and gets its plot wrong."
},
{
"chunk": 65,
"summary": "The bishop says his devout book was praised only by a friend who owed him favours, and that its best hope would be a public denunciation."
},
{
"chunk": 66,
"summary": "The bishop explains that a charge of immorality would sell thousands, needed to fund a church window he has at heart."
},
{
"chunk": 67,
"summary": "The niece blurts out her own fear of not being read; the bishop turns to her novel and asks her to change its title."
},
{
"chunk": 68,
"summary": "The bishop assumes the title was forced on her or chosen innocently, and warns it will offend the readers she should value."
},
{
"chunk": 69,
"summary": "She means to defend her choice but, under the bishop's certainty, begins apologising instead; her husband walks in."
},
{
"chunk": 70,
"summary": "The husband bursts in waving the first review, delighted that the bishop is there to hear it."
},
{
"chunk": 71,
"summary": "The narrator explains that the novelist suffers from a husband who admires everything she does without understanding it."
},
{
"chunk": 72,
"summary": "She wrote the book partly to provoke her husband's disapproval, but he adores it and presses it on everyone."
},
{
"chunk": 73,
"summary": "The husband reads the review aloud in front of the bishop; it begins by denouncing the filth of modern fiction."
},
{
"chunk": 74,
"summary": "The review calls her novel sweetly harmless; weeks later her cousin finds her crushed."
},
{
"chunk": 75,
"summary": "She reveals that every review has called her daring book a pretty, inoffensive story."
},
{
"chunk": 76,
"summary": "The cousin says the bishop blessed the book to bury it, and suggests the bishop could make it sell by denouncing it."
},
{
"chunk": 77,
"summary": "The cousin explains that nobody reads books any more, only puffs, and that only a denunciation from pulpit or press will sell one."
},
{
"chunk": 78,
"summary": "Months later, a famous novelist travelling with her mocks the bishop who publicly attacked her book; she defends her uncle's sense of duty."
},
{
"chunk": 79,
"summary": "Her book has sold a hundred and fifty thousand; strangers recognise and praise her courage on the train."
},
{
"chunk": 80,
"summary": "The bishop's devoted friend tells her the bishop believes the anonymous gift of the window rewarded his courage in denouncing her book."
},
{
"chunk": 81,
"summary": "The friend praises her forgiveness and hints that others think the bishop's attack was deserved."
},
{
"chunk": 82,
"summary": "In the cathedral she enjoys the attention of the congregation and the press, which she owes to the bishop's denunciation."
},
{
"chunk": 83,
"summary": "She plans a more outspoken second novel; the bishop begins his address celebrating the window's mysterious donor."
},
{
"chunk": 84,
"summary": "The bishop hints that the donor was a woman and that a book played its part, and eyes turn to her."
},
{
"chunk": 85,
"summary": "Under everyone's gaze she blushes and panics while the bishop expounds on the power of novels for good or ill."
},
{
"chunk": 86,
"summary": "She nearly walks out, then learns the bishop is crediting his own book with inspiring the gift."
},
{
"chunk": 87,
"summary": "A fellow writer guesses she paid for the window herself; she half denies it, indignant that the bishop claims credit."
},
{
"chunk": 88,
"summary": "A servant weakened by illness and nearly out of money is offered a place by a kindly former acquaintance."
},
{
"chunk": 89,
"summary": "The patron warns that the house is gloomy, the mistress an invalid who lost her children, and the last maid is dead; the servant accepts."
},
{
"chunk": 90,
"summary": "Told to keep out of the master's way, the servant travels to a large dark country house and is received by the cook."
},
{
"chunk": 91,
"summary": "On her way to her room she sees a pale woman in the passage; the housemaid scolds about a room across the hall that must stay locked."
},
{
"chunk": 92,
"summary": "The other servants praise the mistress; the maid meets her and is instantly devoted."
},
{
"chunk": 93,
"summary": "The mistress never uses the bell to her maid's room, always sending the housemaid instead."
},
{
"chunk": 94,
"summary": "No one admits to seeing the pale woman; the cook grows confused when asked where the last maid slept."
},
{
"chunk": 95,
"summary": "The cook begs her not to use the locked room, the dead maid's, and refuses to describe her; the master's arrival puts the household on edge."
},
{
"chunk": 96,
"summary": "The master, a coarse, leering man, looks the maid over and dismisses her; the mistress goes cold in his presence and brightens when he leaves."
},
{
"chunk": 97,
"summary": "A gentle neighbour who shares the mistress's love of books is her only company in winter, and the servants all like him."
},
{
"chunk": 98,
"summary": "The master comes and goes, drinks heavily and grumbles; the servants hint the match was unhappy from the start."
},
{
"chunk": 99,
"summary": "The maid's duties are light and the mistress kind, but she feels a weight whenever she re-enters the house."
},
{
"chunk": 100,
"summary": "Shut in by rain, the maid grows nervous about the locked room; on a trip to town she meets an old colleague who reacts to her employer's name."
},
{
"chunk": 101,
"summary": "The colleague says four maids have left in six months; back at the house the master has arrived and the cook is relieved she returned."
},
{
"chunk": 102,
"summary": "The cook begs her to be good to the mistress; the maid overhears the master jealously accusing his wife over the neighbour."
},
{
"chunk": 103,
"summary": "Uneasy after a tense dinner, the maid is woken at night by her bell ringing for the first time."
},
{
"chunk": 104,
"summary": "She hears the locked room open and steps hurry ahead of her; at her mistress's door the master answers, asking how many of them there are."
},
{
"chunk": 105,
"summary": "The mistress, weak, calls the maid by the dead maid's name; next morning she sends her secretly to fetch medicine and carry a note to the neighbour."
},
{
"chunk": 106,
"summary": "Fearing the mistress means to poison herself, the maid rushes to the chemist and learns the medicine is harmless."
},
{
"chunk": 107,
"summary": "Wondering whether the note was the secret errand, the maid delivers it; the master confronts her and she lies to protect her mistress."
},
{
"chunk": 108,
"summary": "Afraid to stay yet unwilling to abandon her mistress, the maid finds a photograph of the dead maid and recognises the pale woman."
},
{
"chunk": 109,
"summary": "The cook deflects when shown the photograph; the master stays on, taunting his wife about the neighbour's absence."
},
{
"chunk": 110,
"summary": "The neighbour calls and all seem friendly, but the maid lies awake each night, dreading the silence of the locked room, and cannot bring herself to leave."
},
{
"chunk": 111,
"summary": "The mistress grows weaker and more dependent on the maid; with the master away the servants joke about him."
},
{
"chunk": 112,
"summary": "On a cheerful afternoon, for once at ease, the maid looks up and sees the dead maid standing in her doorway."
},
{
"chunk": 113,
"summary": "The apparition looks at her pleadingly and leads her out of the house into the snow."
},
{
"chunk": 114,
"summary": "The figure, leaving no footprints, leads her to the neighbour's gate and waits for her to act."
},
{
"chunk": 115,
"summary": "The neighbour comes out cheerfully; the figure vanishes, and the maid faints, unable to guess the warning."
},
{
"chunk": 116,
"summary": "She makes an excuse to the neighbour, returns home, is sent to bed, and at night hears a door open below."
},
{
"chunk": 117,
"summary": "Her bell rings; she sees the apparition at the stairhead and hears a key in the front door; the mistress, still dressed, denies ringing and sends her away."
},
{
"chunk": 118,
"summary": "The maid warns that the master has returned; the mistress collapses, and the master pushes past, heading for the dressing room to meet a friend."
},
{
"chunk": 119,
"summary": "The apparition appears in the doorway; the master recoils; the mistress dies. At the funeral the master glares at the pale neighbour, then leaves."
},
{
"chunk": 120,
"summary": "A clever, condescending husband notices his simple wife glowing and teases her into admitting she has done something he will not like."
},
{
"chunk": 121,
"summary": "The wife, who holds only inherited opinions, says she expects his disapproval and has allowed for it, then announces 'a baby'."
},
{
"chunk": 122,
"summary": "Baffled, the husband learns she wants the child to be theirs and has long grieved at being childless."
},
{
"chunk": 123,
"summary": "The wife confesses her loneliness and that she chose nursery wallpaper years ago; the husband feels he has failed her."
},
{
"chunk": 124,
"summary": "She asks to adopt an orphan from a hospital, promising it will never bother him."
},
{
"chunk": 125,
"summary": "The husband agrees without resistance, accepting future ridicule as penance for having underestimated his wife."
},
{
"chunk": 126,
"summary": "The husband reflects that he has been faithful but emotionally absent, keeping his wife out of his inner life."
},
{
"chunk": 127,
"summary": "At the hospital the wife is transfigured by the child; the husband feels invisible to her."
},
{
"chunk": 128,
"summary": "The husband allows a legal adoption but refuses to let the child be renamed, and begins to regret the whole business."
},
{
"chunk": 129,
"summary": "The child is quiet and healthy; the wife's character is not changed but magnified by motherhood."
},
{
"chunk": 130,
"summary": "The wife grows assertive and treats the husband as the child's father; he accepts it because she is happy."
},
{
"chunk": 131,
"summary": "The child does not bring the couple together; the wife's personality expands until the husband is squeezed into a corner of his own home."
},
{
"chunk": 132,
"summary": "The girl grows healthy and good, and the wife, feeling unequal to her, asks the husband to take charge of her education."
},
{
"chunk": 133,
"summary": "The wife humbly admits she is too stupid to know what is best for the child and asks the husband to decide."
},
{
"chunk": 134,
"summary": "The girl hoards facts without understanding and grows proud and superior; the wife hopes she will be a companion for the husband."
},
{
"chunk": 135,
"summary": "The girl sets about reforming the whole household, driving off cooks and lecturing the husband until he dines out."
},
{
"chunk": 136,
"summary": "The husband's attempts to check her only hurt his wife; the girl, pretty but charmless, fails in society despite great expense."
},
{
"chunk": 137,
"summary": "The girl takes her failure out on her mother, then turns to charity and makes the husband her evening project."
},
{
"chunk": 138,
"summary": "The wife asks him to bear the girl's attentions; then a young man starts calling, and the parents hardly dare hope he comes for her."
},
{
"chunk": 139,
"summary": "An effusively polite young man courts the girl; the parents pretend not to notice while she shows no emotion at all."
},
{
"chunk": 140,
"summary": "He proposes, and the girl demands a month to think it over, to her parents' agony."
},
{
"chunk": 141,
"summary": "The girl accepts and at once begins to dominate her fiancé; the parents, pitying him, wonder whether to warn him."
},
{
"chunk": 142,
"summary": "The wife tells the fiancé that the girl is always difficult; he says they never understood her and grows cold, which relieves the husband."
},
{
"chunk": 143,
"summary": "The girl turns hysterical before the wedding and threatens to break it off; the husband frets over every possible mishap until the groom arrives late."
},
{
"chunk": 144,
"summary": "The couple leave; alone together at last, the husband and wife draw close and go out to dinner."
},
{
"chunk": 145,
"summary": "A husband gives a fashionable talk arguing that faithfulness to oneself outranks marriage vows; his wife notes that he has recently begun preaching publicly what he used to keep private."
},
{
"chunk": 146,
"summary": "The hosts are a couple who trade on an artistic reputation and recruit daring speakers to keep their gatherings fashionable."
},
{
"chunk": 147,
"summary": "The wife, who once urged these views on him, now finds them vulgarised, and resents the hosts' young daughter hearing such talk."
},
{
"chunk": 148,
"summary": "The young woman asks the wife whether she believes it all; the wife blushes and says the girl doesn't understand."
},
{
"chunk": 149,
"summary": "The wife sees her husband absorbed in the young woman; walking home, he says he spoke publicly to please her, and she asks him to stop."
},
{
"chunk": 150,
"summary": "He is solicitous, but that evening presses her to explain her objection, which she cannot."
},
{
"chunk": 151,
"summary": "Looking round their home, she feels suddenly estranged; he asks whether she no longer believes the ideas their marriage was founded on."
},
{
"chunk": 152,
"summary": "She insists she still believes, but says public talk suits only certain audiences; he reminds her they met in just such a set, and she names the young woman."
},
{
"chunk": 153,
"summary": "He defends the young woman's independence of mind and admits she interests him."
},
{
"chunk": 154,
"summary": "The wife's earlier divorce was accepted by everyone; her first husband was thought impossible, and remarrying a poorer man made her look disinterested."
},
{
"chunk": 155,
"summary": "She recalls her first husband as a dull, self-absorbed man who shaped everything around his own needs."
},
{
"chunk": 156,
"summary": "She remembers his mute bewilderment when she left, and her conviction that a marriage kept up out of duty is a crime."
},
{
"chunk": 157,
"summary": "She met her second husband in the heat of her revolt; he shared her views, and they agreed either could leave when love ended."
},
{
"chunk": 158,
"summary": "Ten years of happiness have made her possessive; she now feels their compact could not apply to them, and takes a nerve tonic."
},
{
"chunk": 159,
"summary": "Her husband is unusually gentle, which frightens her; when he plans to continue the talks she reminds him she objected."
},
{
"chunk": 160,
"summary": "She says she hates hearing him say spouses may leave when tired; he reminds her that was her own reason for leaving her first husband."
},
{
"chunk": 161,
"summary": "He accuses her of dropping the doctrine once it had served her, then claims her promise to release him; she says she will not go back on it."
},
{
"chunk": 162,
"summary": "She guesses he means to marry the young woman, wishes him luck, and is left alone, feeling her home is no longer hers."
},
{
"chunk": 163,
"summary": "Hours pass in stupor; every familiar object in the house mocks her."
},
{
"chunk": 164,
"summary": "She considers fighting through the law or begging, but sees she is trapped by the code she herself made."
},
{
"chunk": 165,
"summary": "She goes to warn the young woman, finds her out, and wanders the streets."
},
{
"chunk": 166,
"summary": "Faint, she takes bitter tea in a shabby eating-house and feels her mind clear."
},
{
"chunk": 167,
"summary": "She sees that warning the girl would have been humiliating, and walks the darkening streets not knowing what to do."
},
{
"chunk": 168,
"summary": "She finds herself outside her first husband's house, watches him go in, and on impulse rings the bell."
},
{
"chunk": 169,
"summary": "She talks her way past the footman; her first husband, shocked, receives her to avoid a scene."
},
{
"chunk": 170,
"summary": "In the unchanged room he coldly suggests she speak through lawyers; she says lawyers cannot help this time."
},
{
"chunk": 171,
"summary": "He braces as if for a request for money; she tells him her husband has left her because he tired of her."
},
{
"chunk": 172,
"summary": "He says she need not grant a divorce; she replies that he did not have to either, and asks whether he, too, never understood."
},
{
"chunk": 173,
"summary": "He admits he never understood; she asks his forgiveness, shakes his hand, and leaves before he can stop her."
},
{
"chunk": 174,
"summary": "A young assistant hired to catalogue an elderly former adventurer's papers is told to get him to talk about his past, which he never discusses."
},
{
"chunk": 175,
"summary": "Going blind, the old man begins to talk of the underground struggle for independence, where prisoners died rather than betray their friends."
},
{
"chunk": 176,
"summary": "Asked for the bravest thing a woman ever did, he says it was provoked by an act of his own he is not proud of."
},
{
"chunk": 177,
"summary": "As a young officer he was sent to an occupied city to help its secret resistance, which carried on its social life in defiance."
},
{
"chunk": 178,
"summary": "He fell in love with a widowed noblewoman prominent in the cause, whose family had been ruined by a ruler's betrayal of his own conspirators."
},
{
"chunk": 179,
"summary": "Her teenage brother was hanged on flimsy evidence after the failed conspiracy, and her mother never recovered."
},
{
"chunk": 180,
"summary": "The daughter, rejecting her mother's brooding, threw herself into the cause after an unhappy marriage and worked for it with great discretion."
},
{
"chunk": 181,
"summary": "Mother and daughter both work for the cause, the mother for vengeance and the daughter for the country, and the daughter reveres her mother's suffering."
},
{
"chunk": 182,
"summary": "The daughter says her mother is tormented that her son alone left no farewell letter; all her bribes to find one failed."
},
{
"chunk": 183,
"summary": "The narrator understands that last letters from the executed were treasured and shared, and that the mother's lack of one isolates her."
},
{
"chunk": 184,
"summary": "She loved another, a leading patriot devoted only to the cause, whose father had been physician to the prisons where her brother died."
},
{
"chunk": 185,
"summary": "The patriot conspired safely under cover of his loyal father's position; she shared his caution and hid fugitives for him."
},
{
"chunk": 186,
"summary": "The narrator, jealous, accused her of leading him on and sneered at her hero; they parted in anger."
},
{
"chunk": 187,
"summary": "After the city rises and is freed, the wounded narrator, sulking, goes to help the new government sort the fallen ruler's archives."
},
{
"chunk": 188,
"summary": "In the archives he finds the hanged boy's farewell letter, marked as handed to the warder by his rival."
},
{
"chunk": 189,
"summary": "He reasons that the rival must have surrendered the letter to curry favour, and so must be a traitor."
},
{
"chunk": 190,
"summary": "Ignoring the rival's long record of courage, the narrator rushes back in anger to the woman he loves."
},
{
"chunk": 191,
"summary": "He calculates that the letter, bound to be published at a coming commemoration, would ruin the rival, and cannot honourably withhold it."
},
{
"chunk": 192,
"summary": "He gives her the letter; overjoyed, she kisses his hands, thinking of the comfort it will bring her mother."
},
{
"chunk": 193,
"summary": "He tells her who gave up the letter; she coolly asks for proof and does not cry out against the man she loves."
},
{
"chunk": 194,
"summary": "She asks him on his honour whether the note could be a later forgery; he says no, and she accepts the evidence without condemning her hero."
},
{
"chunk": 195,
"summary": "He presses the point that her hero betrayed a friend; she replies that she understands, and that he could not have done otherwise."
},
{
"chunk": 196,
"summary": "She argues that bringing the letter would have endangered the cause, so the boy's friend rightly put the country first."
},
{
"chunk": 197,
"summary": "Convinced despite himself, he asks why the hero never told her; she asks him to keep the letter secret from everyone, even her mother."
},
{
"chunk": 198,
"summary": "She burns the letter rather than risk her mother's anger ruining the hero, and says she can never tell him what she has done for him."
},
{
"chunk": 199,
"summary": "A newly engaged man drops in on the woman he has long kept as an intimate friend, meaning to talk over her meeting with his fiancée."
},
{
"chunk": 200,
"summary": "He prides himself on an art of evading declared feeling, having once been burdened by an avowed love."
},
{
"chunk": 201,
"summary": "He trained his friend over years to hide her feelings and follow his lead in every evasion."
},
{
"chunk": 202,
"summary": "She received his fiancée perfectly; he regrets having announced the engagement by letter, as if he had doubted her."
},
{
"chunk": 203,
"summary": "Missing his candid fiancée, he calls to talk about her and delights in the fresh feelings she stirs in him."
},
{
"chunk": 204,
"summary": "His friend is startled to see him and speaks of this as a last visit; he insists nothing has changed."
},
{
"chunk": 205,
"summary": "She reveals that his fiancée came to see her a second time that morning, which he did not know."
},
{
"chunk": 206,
"summary": "She pities him and hints that a letter may await him; the fiancée came to find out whether anything had happened between them."
},
{
"chunk": 207,
"summary": "He protests that a man's past is his own; she says the fiancée objects even to a mere friendship, and came to see whether he was really free."
},
{
"chunk": 208,
"summary": "Told there had never been an affair, the fiancée was more disturbed, not less: the offence was that nothing had happened."
},
{
"chunk": 209,
"summary": "The friend confesses she loved him all along; the fiancée saw that he used her and cast her aside, and despised them both."
},
{
"chunk": 210,
"summary": "The fiancée wants a man capable of love, not reservations; the friend offers to say she lied, and let him claim a past with her."
},
{
"chunk": 211,
"summary": "Moved, he refuses her sacrifice, saying it would only harm his fiancée; she tells him the fiancée has surely recalled her letter."
},
{
"chunk": 212,
"summary": "A mother devoted to her perfect son senses from his walk that he is coming home to tell her something."
},
{
"chunk": 213,
"summary": "In her exquisite house the son slumps by the fire, defeated, and she feels suddenly a stranger to him."
},
{
"chunk": 214,
"summary": "The son says the girl he loves has refused him on principle, because he owns a scandalous newspaper."
},
{
"chunk": 215,
"summary": "The girl wants him to give up the paper or run it honestly at a loss; he mocks her fashionable ethics."
},
{
"chunk": 216,
"summary": "Mother and son agree one cannot change oneself; the girl cites the mother's own example, and the mother notes the girl's family has never called on her."
},
{
"chunk": 217,
"summary": "The girl admires the mother's goodness; the mother, angry, is told her son is not asking her to make the girl love him."
},
{
"chunk": 218,
"summary": "The son asks his mother to visit the girl and show her that the paper has never touched her life."
},
{
"chunk": 219,
"summary": "The mother calls at the girl's plain, comfortless home and reads failure in the furniture."
},
{
"chunk": 220,
"summary": "The girl is immovable; she says it is the mother's own beautiful example that confirms her refusal."
},
{
"chunk": 221,
"summary": "The mother argues that the girl is sacrificing her son to an idea; the girl says she is sacrificing herself."
},
{
"chunk": 222,
"summary": "The mother pleads that life is made of compromises and love outweighs theories; the girl says that is exactly why she cannot."
},
{
"chunk": 223,
"summary": "Six months later the son has buried his grief in the paper, and the mother seeks refuge in a gallery of paintings."
},
{
"chunk": 224,
"summary": "The unspoken subject has driven mother and son apart; in the gallery she meets the girl."
},
{
"chunk": 225,
"summary": "The girl looks worn and unhappy; the mother offers her a lift, is refused, and turns away."
},
{
"chunk": 226,
"summary": "The girl confesses she followed the mother there, has been unhappy, and now believes the mother was right; she asks whether the son still cares."
},
{
"chunk": 227,
"summary": "The mother says she too has suffered, and now admits the girl was right and she was wrong."
},
{
"chunk": 228,
"summary": "The girl believes love alone could change the son; the mother says she once said the same, before marrying his father."
},
{
"chunk": 229,
"summary": "The mother says she speaks because the girl is as alive as she once was, and she cannot watch her be walled up."
},
{
"chunk": 230,
"summary": "She married without knowing what the paper was, enjoyed its money, then learned it traded in exposing private scandal."
},
{
"chunk": 231,
"summary": "The girl tries to stop her from going on."
},
{
"chunk": 232,
"summary": "Her husband promised to sell the paper in time, but her delicate son's life depended on the money, and she sank deeper with each compromise."
},
{
"chunk": 233,
"summary": "She tried to purify the money through charity and to hide the paper from her son behind beauty; on her husband's death she hoped the son would sell it."
},
{
"chunk": 234,
"summary": "At twenty-one the son refused to sell, loving the power the paper gave; she saw he was what her concessions had made him."
},
{
"chunk": 235,
"summary": "She gave up the struggle and learned to look only at the side of her son that was hers."
},
{
"chunk": 236,
"summary": "She warns that the son's love would never change him and that the girl would slowly die as she did; she asks what to tell him, and leaves."
},
{
"chunk": 237,
"summary": "An old man's tale begins with his younger self, just of age, sighting a fabled foreign city from his father's merchant ship."
},
{
"chunk": 238,
"summary": "The youth recalls a childhood print of the city's crowded square, full of foreigners, performers and pickpockets."
},
{
"chunk": 239,
"summary": "The city has always stood in his mind for a place of magic where the rules of his strict upbringing do not hold."
},
{
"chunk": 240,
"summary": "His tutor insists on finishing a sermon before going ashore; the youth slips away alone."
},
{
"chunk": 241,
"summary": "In the crowded square he overpays a pedlar through ignorance of the coinage, and a pleasant English-speaking stranger offers help."
},
{
"chunk": 242,
"summary": "The friendly stranger, calling himself a count, shows him the town and points out its great personages in their odd costumes."
},
{
"chunk": 243,
"summary": "Bound to return by sunset, he gives the count a costly gift, is led into the cathedral, and meets a pretty girl whose dress catches on his sword."
},
{
"chunk": 244,
"summary": "The count names her as a senator's daughter; a page slips the youth a note begging his help, and an officer seizes him."
},
{
"chunk": 245,
"summary": "The count warns him the officer serves the dreaded council and that the letter compromises a great family, and arranges for him to be taken privately to the father."
},
{
"chunk": 246,
"summary": "He asks to send word to his ship and is refused; the count urges him not to resist."
},
{
"chunk": 247,
"summary": "He breaks free and runs, is cornered in an alley, and is pulled through a gate by a servant girl."
},
{
"chunk": 248,
"summary": "He is led to the girl from the cathedral, who seems dismayed to see him; the page was her maid in disguise."
},
{
"chunk": 249,
"summary": "She says the letter was meant for an ambassador to save her from a forced marriage; her father is heard coming."
},
{
"chunk": 250,
"summary": "The father and his noble friends burst in with drawn swords; the count arrives and mediates, and says the youth is in great trouble."
},
{
"chunk": 251,
"summary": "He is accused of secret correspondence with the girl, now repudiated by her betrothed; he refuses to hide behind her word."
},
{
"chunk": 252,
"summary": "Asked to clear her by showing the letter, he sees her silently beg him not to."
},
{
"chunk": 253,
"summary": "He refuses to show his private letters; the count says honour now demands he marry the girl."
},
{
"chunk": 254,
"summary": "He is told he must marry her within the hour, and is locked in with her while the chaplain is fetched."
},
{
"chunk": 255,
"summary": "She weeps with shame, thanks him for keeping her secret, and says her father is forcing her to marry a brute."
},
{
"chunk": 256,
"summary": "She says she cannot be saved but he can, if he will do as she says without looking at her."
},
{
"chunk": 257,
"summary": "She explains that everyone involved can be bought, and begs him to offer a ransom to go free."
},
{
"chunk": 258,
"summary": "He offers to marry her himself instead; she refuses and insists she must marry the other man."
},
{
"chunk": 259,
"summary": "He declares his love; she kisses him, takes a trinket from his watch-chain, and laughs strangely that she will get none of the money."
},
{
"chunk": 260,
"summary": "He realises the whole thing was a swindle; she admits it but says her love was real, just as his ship's captain and tutor arrive with the police."
},
{
"chunk": 261,
"summary": "The captain exposes the tricksters as known confidence men, softens towards the girl, and takes the youth back to his ship."
}
]
}