M3's review recommended planning changes and, following the M2 pattern,
reported rather than applied them. This applies them, and adds the ADR the
review asked for.
ADR 012 records the architecture rather than the requirement. ADR 005
already says that going backward must preserve abandoned history and that
the user sees Undo/Redo/Retry rather than branch management; it names a
movable active head as the direction and stops. What M3 settled is the
shape: the head is stored rather than derived, every read of the story is
capped at it in one place, one mechanism moves it, the state of a position
comes off the node rather than from a replay, the first write below a
moved-back head is the divergence, and whether Redo exists is decided by
the lineage rather than by a flag that could be stale. The last of those
is the property worth keeping — a flag can be wrong and make the story
wrong; a lineage cannot.
Two semantics are ratified in STORY-BRANCH-SEMANTICS.md, both of them
reversals or narrowings that a reader would otherwise take for bugs. Undo
now crosses fork points and continues to the campaign opening, because
refusing at the fork was a consequence of deleting rows the parent line
was also reading, and nothing is deleted any more. And the system refuses
to switch which take is live while a later story is off screen, because
doing it quietly would leave retained history continuing from words the
story no longer says.
A new §14A covers editing in place. §14-15 describe the finished
behaviour — the edit becomes authoritative, the state it implies is
re-evaluated, a new continuation is created, the original is retained —
and that requirement is intact and explicitly not weakened here. It is
also not built, because re-evaluating state from prose a user typed needs
M5's extraction pass. §14A says what exists in the meantime and why
refusing is the minimum that holds the invariant rather than the
destination.
TECHNICAL-DESIGN.md gains §8.7 and §9.1, recording the implemented model
and the bundle behaviour as fact in the way §5.2 records M1 and M2. §10.4
gains a constraint that is easy to lose: the snapshot half of the hybrid
state model is a requirement, not an optimization. Head movement is a row
lookup plus a restore, which is why Undo, Redo and Save Point restore cost
the same at any distance into a campaign; a state model recoverable only
by replaying from the opening would make all three proportional to
campaign length, on exactly the long campaigns this product is for.
DATA-MODEL.md records the head as stored on the campaign rather than
derived from its newest turn — two campaigns holding identical turns can
be read at different places, and nothing about the turns can tell them
apart — and the branch disposition as implemented: the depth a divergent
write left the branch at, deliberately advisory, and carried through
export because every row of an abandoned line is exported either way.
BUILD-MILESTONES.md marks M3 complete and states the one condition still
open. M4 is told a Save Point is a durable pointer and that restoring one
is head movement with a bounds check, not a restore system: a second
mover is the specific failure to avoid, because the two paths would
silently disagree about what restore means. M5 gets three constraints —
keep state efficiently recoverable, move the test instrumentation rather
than the assertions when the world-state protocol goes, and finish the
narrator edit §14A defers.
V1-ACCEPTANCE-TESTS.md clarifies ownership without lowering a bar. D10
keeps all three pass conditions and is explicitly recorded as *not*
satisfied at the end of M3; what changed is that the document now says
which milestone delivers which condition. D03's result is recorded as a
full pass rather than the partial the text allowed for, I07 gains the
pre-M3 bundle clause, and L01 gains the note that resolves its apparent
conflict with A05 — a failed turn does advance the head by one, onto the
player's retained input, and that is A05 working rather than L01 failing.
README.md described a different application: a hosted demo, guest
accounts, cloud providers, Postgres, a Render blueprint, an analytics
dashboard, a QuickJS scripting engine, and 549 tests. M2 removed all of
that and the README was never updated — a gap M2's own debt table missed.
It now describes what this fork is, including the endpoint policy and the
TLS behaviour, and the numbers in it are the current ones.
M3's report is included here as its own evidence record: no separate
baseline report was produced, so it carries the raw counts and runtime
observations as well as the review, and §W records this closeout.
SPECIFICATION.md and SECURITY-THREAT-MODEL.md are unchanged. M3 altered no
product requirement and touched no path in the threat model.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01QF5TcoB86QADgjHz1GZe8u
Phase 17 splits the four files that hold most of the code, finishes the
schema migration SP8 left half done, and stops the published guide from
drifting away from its Markdown source. `plan/17-refactor.md` carries the
plan and the progress table, and `plan/STATUS.md` points at it.
Stage 0 is hygiene only. Both abandoned worktrees are gone, which freed
about 104 MB. Removing `sp7-tree-ui` needed one extra step: a Vite dev
server had been running out of it since 2026-08-18, holding
`frontend/.vite` open and owning port 5173, and serving a tree 54 commits
behind `main`. The three stale `.db` files are deleted; `data.db` is not.
`AIDND_TRUSTED_PROXY_HOPS` is now documented. It was read at `limits.py:55`
and named in no `.env.example`, README, or blueprint. It sets how many
proxy hops the rate limiter trusts in `X-Forwarded-For`, so a deployment
that adds a hop without setting it gets the bucket-rotation bypass back.
The 19 squash-landed branches are still there. `git branch -D` is blocked
by the permission classifier; the verified command is in the plan file.
549 tests pass.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_014Dix4oGV3njgWRdu7P9t6r
`previous_titles` stops a rename stranding the row it left behind, but the rows
already stranded still had to be deleted by hand on every deployment. The
seeder now removes them on the next boot, which retires the stale "Road to the
Champion" demo without a database console.
Only rows with a NULL owner and `is_public` are considered, and a player's own
scenario is neither, so nothing anybody created is reachable. An adventure
started from a deleted demo survives: `adventures.scenario_id` is `ON DELETE
SET NULL`, and the adventure holds its own copies of the cards and scripts, so
it loses only the inherited cover art.
Two cases skip the sweep, because neither is an instruction to remove live
content: a seed file that fails to parse claims no title, and an empty seed
directory reads as a packaging failure.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01PacdRuPXSkQQy4ZYdH32hF
`backend/tools/claude_shim.py` serves an OpenAI-compatible endpoint backed by
the local `claude` command line tool, so a demo can be played against a real
model with no API key. Each request spawns one `claude --print` process, which
suits the turn engine: the app assembles the whole prompt every turn and
expects a stateless endpoint.
Playing the Pokemon demo through it made all five of the world-state changes in
`plan/16` work, and the refusal loop ran end to end for the first time: turn 3
clamped to nothing, turn 4's assembled prompt carried the correction verbatim,
and the model's next delta was right. Two failures previously blamed on the
code were the demo model. One is a schema fault and is still open: Milo's three
Pokemon share one `active_hp` stat, so a switch leaves the newcomer at 0 HP.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01PacdRuPXSkQQy4ZYdH32hF
Trim em dashes, convert first-person plural to second person, and
tighten sentences in README.md, docs/GUIDE.md, docs/self-review.md,
and frontend/README.md, matching the style already applied to code
comments. No technical content, numbers, or code blocks changed.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01N7vUFpYkLrJnuSgwcRjqSx
A hosted demo raises a question a local app never does: is anyone using it,
and do they reach the part that matters? `/analytics` answers it — visitors,
pages, referrers, countries, devices, which shared scenarios get played, turns
and demo-key spend, API and turn errors, and a funnel from visited to played a
turn to signed up.
Not a third-party script, for reasons specific to this one. The CSP allows
`script-src 'self'`, so a tracker means loosening it; adblockers eat the
popular ones, which silently biases exactly the technical audience this
project gets shown to; and none of them can see the measurement that actually
matters here, which is a turn, not a pageview.
**A visit is a write and never a read.** After the 189x egress fix it would be
perverse to add a feature that reads rows per request, so counts accumulate in
a process-local dict and flush every 60s as UPSERTs. Storage is a generic
`(day, metric, label) -> hits` counter, so measuring something new later costs
a constant rather than a migration, plus one row per visitor per day for the
funnel flags. Every dashboard query is a GROUP BY returning tens of rows
however much traffic sits behind it; a month reads back in a few kilobytes.
The buffer's cost is that a hard restart can lose up to a minute — the flusher
also runs on shutdown, and a tier that sleeps when idle sleeps on an empty
buffer anyway.
**The counters are anonymous; the access log beside them is not, on purpose.**
A visitor is `HMAC(secret, "visitor:<user id>")` truncated to 32 chars —
one-way, so `analytics_daily` and `analytics_visitor_days` cannot be joined
back to `users`, and keyed, so no client can compute one. Story content never
reaches that module, and the only content it ever names is a seeded public
scenario's title; a player's own titles are theirs. `accesslog.py` is the
identifying half and is a separate module writing a separate table so that
separation is a property of the code rather than a convention: `access_events`
records sessions, sign-ins, registrations and failed attempts with address,
email and device, read on a second tab of the same page behind the same gate.
Both halves are gated on `AIDND_ANALYTICS_EMAILS`, not `POWER_USERS`. An
unmetered tester is not automatically someone who should see the traffic. The
route 404s and the nav link is absent for everyone else, the same treatment
AI Chat gets; unset in a hosted deploy means nobody sees it, including me.
Three things came out of building it that a test would not have suggested.
**A failed turn is an HTTP 200 with a bad ending.** The status-code middleware
cannot see one, so a demo whose model had started refusing every request would
look perfectly healthy from outside. All five SSE error paths in
`_generate_turn` now go through a `turn_error()` helper that counts on the way
out. Error buckets elsewhere are labelled by the matched route template rather
than the requested path — one bucket per endpoint instead of one per adventure
id, and, the reason it isn't merely tidier, an unmatched path is entirely
attacker-chosen, so labelling by it would let anyone mint rows.
**The funnel counts people, not clicks.** A player who starts six adventures
is one person who started an adventure. That is the whole reason the
per-visitor-day table exists; its flags only ever turn on, and `is_new` is
settled by the first write of a visitor's first day.
**The tests run on SQLite and production is Neon.** A flush that raises is
caught and logged, so a dialect mistake in the UPSERTs would have stayed
invisible until the dashboard quietly never filled.
`test_the_upserts_compile_for_postgres` compiles both statements against the
Postgres dialect without connecting to one.
Two things this leans on elsewhere. `limits._client_ip` is now public
`client_ip`: the access log needs the same answer, and two functions both
deciding which hop is the caller's is how one of them ends up trusting a
header it shouldn't. And the cleanup sweeper now starts if *either* job has
work — a deployment can keep every guest forever and still want its
visitor-day rows aged out.
No migration. Both tables are new and `bootstrap()` calls `create_all` on
existing databases too, the route `branches` took in Phase 14, so
`LATEST_VERSION` is still 64.
497 tests green, frontend lint and build clean, driven by hand against a
synthetic 90-day fixture at 1568px. The narrow-screen layout follows the
existing 720px block but is unverified: `resize_window` is ignored on a
maximized Chrome and `frame-ancestors 'none'` rules out checking it in a sized
iframe. Also repaired here: a rename in test_ratelimit_hardening.py had run
through the test names themselves, leaving `testclient_ip_*` — still collected
by pytest, which is why it passed unnoticed.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01DfMCsN1KBLsTqMkj5hSgrY
The README, the project page and the engineering guide all describe a linear
story. The tree shipped two days ago. Every published surface is a phase
behind, and the guide is not merely behind — it is wrong in a way that costs a
reader time.
Its 2.2 was "Two coordinate systems, and the bug class they create", and it
explained the codebase through position_of_index, note_action_removed and
settled_story_actions. All three were deleted in SP3. 2.3 explained retry
through Action.variants and state_before. Somebody reading either would go
looking for machinery that is not there, which is worse than a gap.
So 2.2 is now "The story is a tree", written at the depth 1.2 and 1.3 are
written at: the seven bugs that turned out to be one bug, the lineage clause
and the two properties that make fork count free, why takes group by parent_id
rather than by coordinate, cursors becoming anchors, and a closing list of what
the design is honest about. 2.3 is rewritten around state_after and takes, and
1.1 and 1.5 follow, because the pipeline no longer snapshots before the call
and the memory bank no longer holds an action back.
The numbers were simply old: 151 tests where there are 440, 37 migrations where
there are 64, twelve phases where there are fourteen. They appear in four
places across the README, the project page's stat tiles and the guide's results
table. The measured branch cost — 103 B, and 1.007x the page load of the same
story flat — is added beside the egress and turn-cost figures it belongs with,
since it is the number that answers "what does branching cost me".
Three screenshots, on a new tools/shots_fixture.py: the Bandit Camp demo driven
through eight written turns with written deltas, three discarded takes forked
onto branches of their own, one off a branch so the map has to nest. Same
reason tree_fixture.py is committed — the shots have to be reproducible and the
frontend still has no test runner. play-world-state.jpg is reshot because it
predates the entire tree UI; the map and the branches panel are new.
Note for next time: docs/guide.html is hand-written, not generated from the
Markdown, so every guide edit is two edits in two vocabularies. Both files were
checked for tag balance and both pages rendered locally before this landed.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01DfMCsN1KBLsTqMkj5hSgrY
The hero linked at the Render hostname directly. Pointing it at the project
page keeps the deploy URL out of the README and folds in the "prefer a tour
first?" line, which pointed at the same place.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01PoBAfwRzHozF2bhZumxjPk
The README says what the project does; nothing said why any of it works the
way it does. This adds design notes written to be read end to end: each
section states the decision, the reasoning, and what it cost.
docs/GUIDE.md is the readable source. docs/guide.html is the same material as
a self-contained reading page for the project site — no webfonts, no scripts
beyond a progress rail, so it also works saved to disk and opened offline.
Covers the context budget allocator, the propose-and-referee world-state
engine, the measured length-hint result, the memory bank's settled-action and
cursor rules, the two coordinate systems behind the summarization bugs, the
retry variant machinery, the egress fix, and the demo-key pinning. Closes with
the measured numbers, the known limitations, and a pointer to the cleanup
backlog in self-review.md.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01PoBAfwRzHozF2bhZumxjPk
The demo sleeps on Render's free tier, so a cold link looks broken to
anyone who won't wait 30-60s. A static page on GitHub Pages is never
asleep: it shows the screenshots immediately and sets the expectation
before the visitor clicks through to the demo.
Served from main:/docs, reusing the screenshots already committed there.
Palette and type match the app so the two read as one product.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_015sygnUWH8WnaoKPDp7hXM1
The README claimed screenshots were "coming" and stopped describing the
project around phase 10, so the world-state engine, the retry/undo state
revert and the egress work — the most interesting parts — were invisible.
- Screenshots of the play screen, Insights, the schema editor and the
script editor, captured from the running app.
- Document the world-state engine, undo/retry rewind, and the two measured
performance fixes; correct the context assembly order to match
context/builder.py; drop the stale "phases 1-6 complete" note.
- Add CI (backend pytest, frontend lint + build, Docker image build) and
its badge. Nothing ran the 151 tests but me.
- Move CODE_REVIEW_FINDINGS.md to docs/self-review.md and say up front
that every correctness finding is resolved.
- Drop a dead import that the newly-wired lint flagged.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_015sygnUWH8WnaoKPDp7hXM1
- When a model streams reasoning but no story text, return a specific,
actionable error (raise Max output tokens / set a reasoning cap / use a
non-reasoning model) instead of the opaque "empty response".
- Bump default max_output_tokens 400 -> 800: 400 truncated scenes and
left reasoning models with no room after thinking. Affects new settings
rows; existing users keep their value.
- README: add a "Try it live" link to the Render deployment.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01TEpWMjnfPqzZ13nPMoGhs5
Guest-first multi-user mode behind AIDND_MULTI_USER (local installs
unchanged): signed-cookie guest sessions bootstrapped by /api/auth/me,
register upgrades the guest in place, login/logout, per-IP rate limits.
Every router scoped by user_id; Settings become per-user with the API
key Fernet-encrypted at rest and write-only through the API. Users
without a key get a server-funded demo key (OpenRouter free models,
20 turns/day, memory bank disabled on demo turns). Public read-only
demo scenarios (seed_demo.py); debug log restricted to local mode.
Frontend: auth modal + guest nudge, 401 re-establish/retry, demo
banner and key management in Settings.
Migrations 13-23 adopt existing data under a local user and encrypt
stored keys. Verified: migration on a copy of real data.db, two-session
isolation + register/login via curl and Chrome, demo cap 429, live
OpenRouter turn through the encrypted-key path, vite build + oxlint.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01KFsGHju9szibJJa2YJcdbg
- LICENSE: MIT
- README: rewritten as portfolio-grade docs (features with code pointers,
architecture, Docker/Windows/macOS quick starts, BYO-model table)
- Dockerfile (3-stage: SPA build, pip wheels, slim runtime) + compose with
a /data volume; .dockerignore keeps secrets and local data out
- database.py: AIDND_DB_PATH env override so deployments can relocate the
SQLite file; documented in backend/.env.example
- start.sh: macOS/Linux dev script with first-run setup
Verified locally: production SPA build served by the backend (deep links
OK), DB created at the override path. Docker image itself untested here
(Docker not installed); flagged in plan/07.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01KFsGHju9szibJJa2YJcdbg
