Reported after updating to v0.5.4: clicking Multiplayer went straight into
a game with no lobby and no controls, and the board was blank.
Three things lined up. start() enters a remembered session WITHOUT checking
it still exists — that is what makes reconnection seamless, and it is why
the lobby was skipped. The v0.5.4 update had refused to resume that game,
its save being recorded under v0.5.3 and the engine-version check being
exact (D7). And createRemoteSession had no onerror at all, so EventSource
retried the resulting 404 forever in silence while frame stayed null and
nothing rendered. The only escape was clearing site data, and nothing on
screen said so.
v0.5.3's Manage Game -> End had just widened the same dead end: it closes
every watcher's stream, so a player whose game an administrator ended would
sit frozen on a stale board indefinitely, for exactly the same reason.
GET /api/session?token= is new: a cheap yes/no on whether a token still
names a live game. EventSource fires error identically for a transient blip
— the expected shape of a game idle for minutes (§9) — and for a 404 it
will retry forever, and exposes no status code either way, so the client
asks rather than guessing. Only a definite 404 closes the stream and
reports the game gone; a flaky network still self-heals.
The page then forgets the stored session, says why (ended by an
administrator, or the service was updated, which does not carry games
across), and drops into the lobby. Forgetting the token is what stops the
next load repeating it. It also stops rendering nothing while it waits —
"… connecting to the game" sits in the presence banner until the first push
arrives, because a page showing nothing is indistinguishable from a broken
one, which is what this looked like.
Recorded but NOT fixed, in TODO.md: three releases in a row destroyed every
game in progress, and v0.5.4's changes were rendering only. The refusal is
right, but the test is exact equality against the PACKAGE version, which
moves for reasons unrelated to the rules. Three options costed; the
recommendation is to replay the save and refuse only if an intent actually
rejects — the real question rather than a proxy for it, and a full replay
measures ~100 ms.
Verified live: /api/session answers 200 for a seated token, 404 once an
administrator ends the game, 404 for a garbage token, and /api/stream 404s
in the same state — which is the response EventSource had been retrying
silently. 673 tests pass.
A real server existed since v0.5.0 but nobody could reach it without a hand-built ?seat=&secret=
URL. This is what makes it a game you can actually create or join.
The server now hosts more than one game: src/server/lobby.ts (new) is pure logic — creating,
joining, bot seats, host transfer, starting — same split session.ts already draws for a running
game. persistence.ts gained one directory per gameId plus a top-level index so index.ts resumes
every saved game on boot. /api/stream and /api/intent now authenticate by session token instead of
?seat=&secret= — the token alone proves identity (lobby-and-sessions.md §1), so the join secret's
job ends at the lobby door.
Bots fill empty seats at Lobby.Start only, never take over a disconnected human (D8): session.ts
gained driveBots(), playing developerBot forward through consecutive bot seats after every accepted
intent. Disconnect keeps the seat and says so — Push gained an optional presence field, built
entirely by http.ts and never routed through the engine, since a disconnect is transport news, not
a GameEvent. Host rights pass to the earliest-joined remaining player if the host drops before
start.
Client: src/web/lobby.ts adds create/join forms and a live seating screen; localStorage replaces
?seat= for reconnecting straight back into a game already joined. A Multiplayer button sits beside
New game; the New Game dialog itself is untouched.
Found only by the live smoke test, not by typechecking: /api/intent read its token from the JSON
body while the client sends it in the query string (matching /api/stream) — every intent failed
"no such game" until caught by curl-level verification.
Doc fix: multiplayer.md's D18 said the player cap was 6; lobby-and-sessions.md §2 says 2-4 with the
reasoning and the test coverage to back it. The two had drifted apart. D18 now reads 2-4.
Not verified: an actual browser walking through the lobby screens — none available in this
environment, same limitation Phase 2's RemoteSession shipped under. 656 tests, 0 failures.
tools/jitsi-harness/ deliberately left untracked — unrelated side-project work, not part of this
release.
Phases 0-1 shipped in v0.4.0 (seat/identity split, per-player turn state, the Session boundary).
This lands Phase 2 (server core, one game, no lobby) and Phase 3 (persistence and resumption) per
docs/architecture/multiplayer.md §12. Phases 4-6 (lobby/reconnection, the 22 opponent-directed
cards, StartOS packaging) are still ahead.
Phase 2: src/server/session.ts hosts a game in pure logic (no sockets) on top of game.ts's existing
Game/submit/currentActor/actionMenu; it verifies seat === currentActor(game) itself before calling
submit, since submit() trusts its caller and a server can't. src/server/http.ts and index.ts add
POST /api/game, GET /api/stream (SSE, per-seat), POST /api/intent, and static serving of dist/.
src/sim/frame-delta.ts is a purpose-built per-seat board delta for one live push at a time. Found
and fixed along the way: actionMenu(game, seat) only used seat for the hand field, so a server
computing every connected seat's Menu would have handed the acting player's legal moves to a
waiting seat. Verified with a live end-to-end smoke test (2-player game, two SSE streams, a
rejected intent from the wrong seat, an idempotent resend) plus test/server/session.test.ts and
test/redaction.test.ts. Not verified: an actual browser (none available in this environment).
Phase 3: src/server/persistence.ts writes game.json and turn-timings.json, atomic-rewrite-then-
rename. game.ts gained fromMultiplayerSave, fixing a narration-attribution bug found while testing
it (fromSave's replay loop drops the actor argument, invisible in solitaire, unreadable the moment
there's more than one seat — fromSave itself still has this gap, deliberately untouched). Verified
live: server killed and restarted mid-game, both seats reconnected exactly where they left off.
Two rules bugs found while building this: the New Train phase never implemented its car-placement
round (every car of every train was placed by the Superintendent alone, in every mode, all along —
now reads the round position off tray.consist.length); and victory conditions are now one shared,
configurable GameConfig set across solitaire/competitive/coop instead of a fixed length lookup and
a dead firstToTarget condition.
Also folds in the three fixes already released on the patch line as v0.4.9b/c/d: a switching
train's crew badge failing to draw once it left the Office square, an unload that always took the
westmost car regardless of which was picked, and a legal decision that could render with zero
buttons.
docs/testing/0.5.0-test-plan.md and three reported-bug save files (docs/station-master-seed*.json)
included for reproducibility. tools/jitsi-harness/ deliberately left untracked — unrelated
side-project work, not part of this release. 635 tests, 0 failures.
Jesse